Caledon Hills Realty Ltd. v Rosario

Split/Other wins · Orangeville · 2018-01-08

Adjudicator

James Marentette

Dispute

Cleaning, Damage to Property, Unpaid Rent

Amount

<$5K

Landlord

Caledon Hills Realty Ltd.

Tenant

W.R., A.R.

Landlord rep

A. Adams

Tenant rep

V. Chagnon

What happened

Landlord applied for damages against former tenants for unpaid rent, utility costs, repair of unreasonable damage, and lost rent during repairs. Tenants defended and filed a counterclaim for damages, loss of amenities, abatement of rent, and punitive damages due to landlord's failure to maintain the rental unit.

The ruling

The landlord's claim is dismissed, except for $150.14 owed for utilities. The tenants' counterclaim is dismissed, except for $100 owed to them for basement cleanup costs. The net amount owed by the tenants to the landlord is $50.14.